Amazon's Deduction Machine: How the Everything Store Takes Everything (Including Your Profit Margin)

If you sell products through Amazon's first-party vendor program (Vendor Central), you don't sell on Amazon — you sell to Amazon. They buy your products wholesale, then resell them. Simple, right?

Here's where it gets interesting. And by "interesting," we mean "financially devastating."

Amazon has built what can only be described as an industrial-scale deduction machine. Through a byzantine system of shortage claims, price claims, chargebacks, and compliance penalties, Amazon systematically reduces what it pays vendors — often by significant amounts, often without clear justification, and always with the burden of proof resting squarely on the supplier's shoulders.

Industry data tells the story: 97% of Amazon vendor deductions are shortage-related. Vendors report losing between 1% and 5% of total revenue to these deductions, with some losing up to 14%. On a $10 million account, that's anywhere from $100,000 to $1.4 million vanishing into Amazon's fulfillment machine every year.

Step 1: You Ship Your Products

You receive a purchase order. You pack and ship exactly what was ordered, with meticulous labeling and documentation. So far, so good.

Step 2: Amazon "Receives" Your Products

Amazon's fulfillment centers — massive, chaotic warehouses where robots and humans process millions of items daily — check in your shipment. If their count doesn't match your invoice, they generate a shortage claim. This happens roughly five days before your invoice is due for payment.

Step 3: The Deduction Appears

Amazon pays your invoice but simultaneously creates a second invoice deducting the "shortage" amount. You might not even notice immediately — the deductions are buried in Vendor Central's payment section and Amazon hides shortage details older than nine months.

Step 4: You Discover You've Been Underpaid

Weeks or months later, you realize your payments don't add up. You dig through Vendor Central's labyrinthine interface and discover thousands — sometimes tens or hundreds of thousands — in accumulated deductions.

Step 5: The Dispute Clock Is Ticking

You have roughly 30 days to file a dispute. You need to provide proof of shipment, delivery confirmation, packing lists, and photographs. For a single deduction. Now multiply that by dozens or hundreds of deductions per quarter. Amazon's policy allows each invoice to be disputed only once.

The resolution process takes up to 35 days. Meanwhile, Amazon may issue additional shortage claims from the same shipments via "Missed Adjustment Claims" (MACs), deducted from future payments.

It's like playing whack-a-mole, except the moles have lawyers.

While the MusicBrainz cake made headlines, the real confrontation happened in the UK, where suppliers started fighting back publicly.

Steve Riordan, managing director of UK IT distributor Smithie UK, went public about Amazon's payment practices, warning his company could be owed £2 million ($2.9 million) within six months. Amazon's reported response? An offer to pay 30% of what was owed. Riordan called even a 50/50 split a "dangerous precedent."

His public statement was a rallying cry: "If other distributors have the money to write off what they're owed, what does that say to the rest of the industry? It lets Amazon think they've got away with it."

At least two UK distributors chose to stop doing business with Amazon entirely. One anonymous vendor told reporters: "I saw the writing on the wall much earlier than some of my competitors, who have clearly been burnt. The only way to get something like this fixed is through legal action."

Another distributor described the problem as "a global phenomenon, not just affecting the UK."

Here's perhaps the most telling indicator of how systemic this problem is: an entire industry has sprung up to help vendors recover money Amazon has deducted.

Companies like SupplyPike, ChannelEngine, Riverbend Consulting, Reason Automation, and Carbon6 have built their entire business models around helping Amazon vendors navigate the deduction labyrinth. SupplyPike alone has helped recover over $1 billion in supplier deductions across major retailers.

ChannelEngine's shortage recovery tool promises to dispute claims going back up to five years. The fact that there's a five-year backlog of questionable deductions tells you everything you need to know about the scale of the problem.

When specialized consulting firms exist solely to help companies get paid by a single buyer, that buyer's payment practices deserve scrutiny.

Consulting firm Riverbend identifies these common Amazon payment issues:

• Refusing to pay invoices when Amazon lost or damaged inventory after receipt — shifting the cost of their own warehouse errors to suppliers
• Wrongly taking "Quick Pay" discounts on items received past the 30-day deadline — essentially taking a discount they didn't earn
• Retroactively auditing vendor agreements and demanding payments from several years ago — the financial equivalent of your landlord suddenly "discovering" you owe back rent from 2019
• Not allowing vendors to submit invoices for items sold prior to the vendor account being closed — if they close your account, any unpaid work simply evaporates

Amazon isn't alone. Walmart operates a similarly aggressive deduction system, where the average supplier loses 5.8% of invoices to deductions, with some losing over 30%. Walmart's OTIF (On-Time In-Full) program penalizes suppliers 3% of cost of goods for delivery timing shortfalls.

The difference is that Walmart's system is more transparent — deduction codes are well-documented, and the dispute process, while arduous, is more structured. Amazon's system, by contrast, operates more like a black box where the rules change without notice and documentation requirements vary depending on which support agent you reach.

The financial damage is obvious, but the hidden costs are worse:

Time: Vendors report spending 15-20 hours per week managing Amazon deductions — time that could be spent growing their business, developing products, or simply staying sane.

Opportunity Cost: Resources dedicated to dispute management are resources not dedicated to innovation, marketing, or other revenue-generating activities.

Cash Flow Strangulation: Deductions create unpredictable cash flow, making it impossible to plan investments, manage payroll, or negotiate with your own suppliers.

Psychological Toll: Multiple vendor testimonials describe the experience as demoralizing, with the constant feeling of being nickeled-and-dimed by a $1.9 trillion company.

Before Becoming an Amazon Vendor:

• Model your profitability assuming 3-5% in deductions from day one
• Build dispute management capacity (human or automated) into your operating budget
• Consider third-party vendor programs versus first-party (Vendor Central) — in marketplace, you control pricing and get paid by the customer
• Research Amazon's dispute processes and documentation requirements thoroughly

If You're Already a Vendor:

• Conduct a comprehensive audit of past transactions — you may have years of recoverable deductions
• Invest in automation tools that flag discrepancies in real-time
• Never let deductions accumulate uncontested — the dispute window is finite
• Document every shipment meticulously: photos of packed goods, carrier tracking, delivery confirmations
• Consider whether the relationship is actually profitable after deductions

Nuclear Options:

• If Amazon owes significant amounts and won't engage, consider formal legal demand
• Engage a B2B debt collection specialist with experience in corporate accounts
• In some jurisdictions, statutory interest on late/unjust payments may apply

Amazon's deduction system isn't a bug — it's a feature. It transfers the cost of warehouse inefficiency, counting errors, and system glitches from a $1.9 trillion company to suppliers that might have $1.9 million in annual revenue.

The cake was funny. The reality isn't.

---

Amazon owes you money? Collecty specializes in B2B debt recovery from corporate accounts across 160+ countries. 80%+ recovery rate. No win, no fee. Start your free assessment →

---