By Collecty Research | Forensic Series: The Giant Client Trap
Reading time: 14 minutes
Over the past six articles, we've documented how Tesla bankrupts contractors, Amazon deducts from invoices, Apple absorbs technology, Walmart penalizes deliveries, France fines offenders, and the UK counts its losses.
Now the question that matters most: What do you actually do about it?
This is the survival guide. Not theory. Not hand-wringing. Practical, jurisdiction-specific, field-tested advice for every small and mid-size business that sells to β or is considering selling to β a corporate giant.
Print this out. Pin it to your wall. Share it with your CFO. Your business may depend on it.
Rule #1: The 30% Rule β Never Let One Client Own Your Future
The single most important principle in supplier survival is also the simplest: no single client should ever represent more than 30% of your revenue.
Many advisors say 40%. Some say 25%. We say 30% because it balances growth opportunity with existential risk. If your largest client stops paying tomorrow β not if, but when, because the data shows it happens β you need to survive the impact.
Here's what client concentration risk actually looks like:
- Under 20%: Manageable. You'll feel the pain, but your business survives intact
- 20-30%: Uncomfortable. You'll need to cut costs and scramble, but recovery is possible within 6 months
- 30-50%: Dangerous. You'll likely need emergency financing, staff reductions, and 12+ months to stabilize
- Over 50%: Existential. If this client stops paying, your business is in immediate jeopardy
Professional Process Piping dedicated its entire workforce to Tesla. Full Circle Technologies built its business around Tesla contracts. GT Advanced invested $900 million in Apple-specific production. All three went bankrupt.
The pattern isn't subtle. The lesson shouldn't require repetition. But it does, because the temptation of a giant contract is powerful enough to override judgment.
Rule #2: The Contract Is the Battlefield β Win It Before You Fight
Every disastrous supplier relationship we've documented began with a contract that favored the buyer. Here are the clauses you must negotiate, refuse, or at minimum understand before signing:
Red Flags in Payment Terms
- Payment terms exceeding 60 days: In France, this is illegal. In the UK, it's about to be capped. In the US, it's common but dangerous. Push back
- "Payment upon acceptance" without defined acceptance criteria: This gives the buyer unlimited time to "review" your work before paying
- Right to offset or deduct without prior written agreement: This is how Amazon and Walmart reduce payments unilaterally
- No late payment interest clause: If the contract doesn't mention late payment interest, statutory rates may still apply β but you need to verify jurisdiction-by-jurisdiction
Red Flags in IP and Work Product
- "All work product belongs to the buyer": Standard in some industries, devastating in others. Negotiate carve-outs for pre-existing IP
- Technology transfer clauses: If the contract allows the buyer to share your processes with third parties, you're funding your own replacement
- Non-compete provisions: If you can't sell your innovation to anyone else, you're a captive supplier
Red Flags in Liability and Risk
- Consignment terms: You bear inventory risk for unsold goods. Budget accordingly
- Unilateral order modification: The buyer can change quantities without compensation. Insist on minimum commitments
- "Buyer's convenience" termination: The buyer can exit at any time. Negotiate termination fees that cover your stranded investments
What a Good Contract Includes
- Payment within 30-45 days of invoice (not delivery, not acceptance)
- Automatic late payment interest at a specified rate
- Milestone-based payments for large projects
- Clear IP ownership with pre-existing IP exclusions
- Minimum volume commitments or take-or-pay provisions
- Mutual termination provisions with reasonable notice periods
- Dispute resolution in a neutral jurisdiction
Rule #3: Document Like a Forensic Accountant
Every single supplier dispute we've documented has hinged on evidence. The companies that survived had documentation. The companies that went bankrupt didn't.
What to document:
- Every purchase order, change order, and communication about scope
- Every delivery with photographic evidence of goods shipped
- Every delivery confirmation with timestamp and receiver signature
- Every email or message confirming acceptance of work
- Every invoice with proof of delivery
- Every payment received with date and amount
- Every communication about payment delays, disputes, or deductions
- Every instance where the client caused delays or problems that affected your performance
Store this documentation in a system that's backed up, timestamped, and accessible to your legal team. Cloud storage with version history is ideal.
When a $1.9 trillion company's legal department disputes your $600,000 invoice, your contemporaneous documentation is your shield. Without it, you're bringing a strongly worded email to a gunfight.
Rule #4: Know Your Legal Rights by Jurisdiction
Payment rights vary significantly by country. Here's your cheat sheet:
πΊπΈ United States
Federal Framework:
- Prompt Payment Act (31 USC Β§3901-3907): Applies ONLY to federal government contracts. Private B2B has no federal late payment law
- UCC Article 2: Governs sales of goods. Payment due at time and place of delivery unless contract specifies otherwise
- State lien laws: Contractors can file mechanics' liens against property they've improved (this is how Tesla's $24M in liens accumulated)
Practical Steps:
- File mechanics' liens immediately when payment is overdue (deadlines vary by state β in Texas, it's within 15 days of the 15th of the month following the work)
- Send formal demand letters via certified mail
- Consider Small Claims Court for amounts under $10,000-$25,000 (varies by state)
- Engage collections early β the older the debt, the harder to recover
Key Limitation: No federal enforcement body for private B2B late payments. You're on your own.
π¬π§ United Kingdom
Legal Framework:
- Late Payment of Commercial Debts (Interest) Act 1998: 8% above Bank of England base rate on overdue payments. This is automatic and statutory
- Fixed compensation: Β£40 (debts under Β£1,000), Β£70 (Β£1,000-Β£9,999), Β£100 (Β£10,000+) per late invoice
- Payment Practices and Performance Regulations 2017: Large companies must publicly report payment practices
2025 Crackdown (Incoming):
- Financial penalties for persistent late payers
- Small Business Commissioner gains enforcement powers
- Maximum 60-day terms (reducing to 45 days)
- Board-level accountability
Practical Steps:
- Include statutory interest notice on every invoice
- Claim fixed compensation from day one of late payment
- Report persistent offenders to the Small Business Commissioner
- Check public payment performance reports before onboarding large clients
π«π· France
Legal Framework:
- Code de Commerce, Article L.441-10: Maximum payment terms of 60 days from invoice or 45 days end of month
- Automatic penalties: 3Γ legal interest rate (currently ~12-15% annualized) + β¬40 fixed indemnity per late invoice
- DGCCRF enforcement: Fines up to β¬2M (β¬4M for repeat offenders), publicly published
Practical Steps:
- Reference Article L.441-10 explicitly in all contracts
- Apply statutory interest and β¬40 indemnity automatically from the first day of late payment
- Report persistent late payers directly to the DGCCRF
- The DGCCRF actively investigates supplier complaints β use this leverage
Key Advantage: France has the world's strongest late payment enforcement. Use it.
π¨π¦ Canada
Legal Framework:
- Federal Prompt Payment for Construction Act (effective 2023): Applies to federal construction projects only. Mandates 28-day payment from invoice to general contractor, 7-day flow-down to subcontractors
- Provincial variations: Ontario's Construction Act (2019) includes adjudication for payment disputes. Quebec's Civil Code provides interest at 5% above Bank of Canada rate. Other provinces vary
- No federal B2B late payment law for non-construction private sector
Practical Steps:
- For federal construction contracts, invoke the Prompt Payment Act immediately
- In Ontario, use the statutory adjudication process for construction disputes β it's fast (binding decision within 46 days)
- File construction liens within provincial deadlines (45 days in Ontario, 30 days in Quebec from completion)
- For non-construction B2B, rely on contractual terms and provincial commercial law
Key Limitation: Outside construction, Canadian late payment enforcement is fragmented. Contractual protection is essential.
π©πͺ Germany
Legal Framework:
- EU Late Payment Directive (2011/7/EU) implemented via German Civil Code (BGB Β§286-288)
- Payment terms: Maximum 60 days unless "expressly agreed" and "not grossly unfair." Default: 30 days
- Late payment interest: 9% above ECB base rate for B2B transactions (currently ~13%)
- Fixed compensation: β¬40 per late invoice (implemented from EU Directive)
Practical Steps:
- Reference BGB Β§286-288 in contracts with German companies
- Apply the 9% above ECB rate from day 31 (or from contractual due date)
- Claim the β¬40 fixed indemnity per invoice
- For significant amounts, engage German commercial courts (Handelsgericht) which are relatively efficient
Key Note: Germany's enforcement is less aggressive than France but the statutory framework is strong. Many German companies pay within terms as a cultural norm β the risks are more concentrated among multinational subsidiaries operating in Germany.
Rule #5: Build Your Early Warning System
Don't wait for a $500,000 unpaid invoice to discover you have a problem. Build systems that catch trouble early:
Financial Monitoring:
- Track DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) by client monthly
- Flag any invoice that reaches 45 days unpaid
- Monitor the ratio of disputed vs. undisputed invoices per client
- Set up automated reminders at 7, 14, 30, and 45 days past due
Relationship Monitoring:
- Note changes in communication patterns (slower responses, different contacts)
- Track scope changes, order reductions, or forecast adjustments
- Monitor public news about your client's financial health
- Watch for changes in payment behavior (partial payments, new deduction types)
Credit Monitoring:
- Subscribe to credit monitoring services for major clients
- Review publicly available financial statements annually
- Track lien filings, lawsuits, and regulatory actions against your clients
- In France and the UK, check public payment performance reports
If three or more early warning signals trigger simultaneously, escalate immediately. Don't wait for confirmation. By the time a $1 billion company's payment problems are confirmed, small suppliers are already underwater.
Rule #6: Have Your Recovery Plan Ready Before You Need It
The time to plan your debt recovery strategy is before the debt exists. Here's a 90-day recovery framework:
Days 1-7: Soft Reminder
- Send a polite but formal payment reminder
- Reference the invoice number, amount, and original due date
- Copy: your main contact + their accounts payable
- Tone: professional, assuming good faith
Days 8-30: Formal Escalation
- Send a formal demand letter via certified mail/tracked email
- Reference contractual terms and statutory late payment provisions
- Apply late payment interest from the due date
- Claim fixed compensation (β¬40/Β£40-100 where applicable)
- Copy: your legal counsel (even if you don't plan to sue yet)
Days 31-60: Professional Intervention
- Engage a B2B debt collection specialist
- Provide complete documentation package
- The specialist sends formal demands with legal authority
- In France: notify the DGCCRF
- In UK: report to Small Business Commissioner
- In USA: verify lien deadlines and file if applicable
Days 61-90: Legal Action Decision
- Review with legal counsel whether formal proceedings are warranted
- Calculate cost-benefit of litigation vs. settlement
- In the UK: consider statutory demand (for debts over Β£750)
- In France: consider injonction de payer (simplified court order)
- In Canada (construction): invoke adjudication
- In Germany: consider Mahnverfahren (simplified payment order)
Beyond 90 Days
- If the client is solvent and simply refusing to pay, legal action may be the only path
- If the client is approaching insolvency, move faster β secured creditors get paid first
- Consider whether the client's behavior constitutes fraud (as Lebronze Alloys alleged against Tesla)
Rule #7: Protect Your Most Valuable Asset β Your Intellectual Property
Apple's playbook has shown that payment delays are not the only risk. Technology transfer, IP appropriation, and competitive cultivation can destroy suppliers who innovate for corporate giants.
Pre-Contract IP Protection:
- Patent key innovations BEFORE entering supplier discussions
- Clearly define and document your pre-existing IP in writing
- Negotiate IP ownership clauses that protect your innovations
- Refuse "all work product" clauses without carve-outs
- Insist on restrictions preventing the buyer from sharing your processes with competitors
During the Relationship:
- Continue filing patents on innovations developed during the engagement
- Document which innovations were your initiative vs. the buyer's specification
- Monitor whether your proprietary methods appear in competitors' products
- Maintain trade secret protections (restricted access, NDAs, documentation)
If You Suspect IP Theft:
- Consult with IP litigation attorneys immediately
- Document the timeline: when you developed the innovation, when the buyer gained access, when competitors began using similar methods
- Consider filing complaints with relevant trade authorities
- In the US: consider International Trade Commission complaints for imported goods using stolen IP
The Master Checklist
Checklist
0 of 22 completeThe Final Word
Landing a corporate giant as a client can be transformative. The revenue is real. The credibility is valuable. The growth opportunity is genuine.
But so is the risk.
Tesla owed $24 million to contractors who helped build its empire. Amazon vendors lose up to 14% of revenue to shortage deductions. Apple suppliers invest billions only to watch their innovations walk out the door. Walmart charges 3% penalties for delivery windows that its own warehouses can't honor. And 50,000 UK businesses close every year because someone decided their invoice could wait.
None of these suppliers expected it. All of them could have prepared for it.
The difference between a giant client that grows your business and a giant client that destroys it isn't luck. It's preparation, diversification, documentation, and the willingness to enforce your rights before it's too late.
The whale is an opportunity. Just make sure you have a boat big enough to survive the ride.
Don't wait for the crisis. Collecty helps B2B businesses recover debts from corporate clients across 160+ countries. 80%+ success rate. No win, no fee. Get your free case assessment β
Sarah Lindberg
International Operations Lead
Sarah coordinates our global partner network across 160+ countries, ensuring seamless cross-border debt recovery.



