A €840K lesson in why German law and Munich venue clauses mean nothing in Shanghai.
The Problem
Many European companies assume their standard contract terms will protect them internationally. They insert "German law applies" or "All disputes in Munich courts" and believe they're covered.
Reality check: These clauses are often unenforceable in jurisdictions like China, where local courts don't recognize foreign venue selections without specific bilateral agreements.
What Happened
A German manufacturer shipped €840,000 worth of industrial equipment to a Chinese distributor. The contract was their "standard European template" with:
- German governing law
- Exclusive jurisdiction in Munich
- Payment terms of Net 60
When the Chinese buyer stopped paying after €340,000, the German company discovered:
- Chinese courts wouldn't enforce the Munich venue clause
- German judgments aren't automatically recognized in China
- The cost of parallel litigation exceeded the debt value
Key Takeaways
1. Venue clauses need bilateral treaty backing. Germany and China don't have a mutual recognition treaty for civil judgments.
2. Arbitration clauses are stronger. China is a signatory to the New York Convention, meaning arbitration awards from recognized bodies ARE enforceable.
3. Local legal review is non-negotiable. A 30-minute review by a Chinese commercial lawyer would have flagged this €840K exposure.
The Fix
For cross-border contracts with China (and many other jurisdictions):
- Use arbitration (CIETAC, ICC, or HKIAC) instead of court jurisdiction
- Specify a neutral seat (Singapore, Hong Kong)
- Include Chinese language versions with equal legal weight
- Get local counsel to review payment security mechanisms
Bottom Line
Your "standard" contract is only standard in your home jurisdiction. International trade requires international thinking.
Collecty specializes in cross-border debt recovery. We know which clauses actually work in which countries—and we've seen the €840K mistakes so you don't have to make them.
Marcus Chen
Senior Collections Strategist
Marcus brings 15 years of international debt recovery experience, specializing in cross-border B2B collections across Europe and Asia-Pacific.


